Hello moms and party planners! If you’re preparing for a baby shower and in search of baby shower game prizes that truly stand out, you’ve landed on the perfect spot. Although gift cards can be a convenient choice for many, there are occasions when they simply lack that special touch.
Let’s face it, baby shower games can be a bit hit or miss depending on the crowd. Adding some incentive for guests to participate can make all the difference, but we get it – the prizes shouldn’t be as corny as the games themselves.
So, if you are looking for something else to spice up your party, I’ve got a list of 33 practical and charming baby shower game prizes your guests are sure to love!
I’ve compiled a selection of baby shower game prizes that are both meaningful and practical. From keepsakes to pampering goodies to everyday essentials, there are so many gifts on this list that your guests will actually WANT to win! I’m sure you’ll find the perfect prize (or prizes) for your party!
Let’s get started.
Pin this image for later so you don’t forget any great prize ideas!
Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links. If purchases are made through these links, I may receive a small commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting this site.
Choosing Baby Shower Game Prizes
There are a few things you should consider when choosing the right baby shower game prizes.
First off should be how many guests you intend to invite and who those people are. A more intimate gathering of just women may make it easier to tailor the gifts to what this group of people may like.
If your event is more co-ed style or even an event for the whole family, you will have to consider different genders and age groups in your prizes. In that case, it would probably be best to have a wide variety of prizes that the winners can select from or just make them all the same. Or if you are planning a virtual baby shower, you may have to choose prizes that are easy to get to the winners later.
Plus, the more guests you have, you may have to consider how many games you will be playing and the number of winners for each, so plan accordingly!
How Much Should You Spend on Baby Shower Game Prizes?
There really is no rule when it comes to how much to spend on you baby shower game prizes. Everyone’s budget will vary, and your prizes should reflect that. Whether you’re organizing a laid-back and informal gathering or a grand, extravagant celebration, allow your baby shower budget to dictate the extent of your prize expenses.
And really a baby shower is not about the guest receiving gifts, but loved ones showering the mom to be, so any prize would be appreciated!
My personal opinion is that smaller prizes if there are a few can range from $5-10 and maybe a grand prize (for a diaper raffle maybe) could be upwards of $20 or more. But again, the budget is completely up to the host/mom-to-be.
Tips for Choosing the Best Baby Shower Game Prizes
- Theme based – If you are stumped on what prizes to get, think of your baby shower theme! I’m sure there are plenty of great ideas that fit into the theme that will double as cute décor.
- Variety – It can be hard to cater exactly to everyone’s likes and dislikes, so get a variety of prizes and let them choose! This way hopefully everyone gets something that they are happy with and will actually use.
- Food allergies – Edible gifts are usually a pretty safe bet but be careful with food allergies if using these are baby shower game prizes.
- Extras – You’ll want to be sure to have as many prizes as you have games to have one for every winner. Depending on the game, there may be ties so having at least one if not a few extras can be helpful.
Top Picks for Baby Shower Game Prizes
Here’s our list of the top baby shower game prizes your guests will actually want to win! Hopefully you will find plenty of ideas here that can fit all sorts of age groups and preferences without breaking the bank!
1. Bath Bombs
Bath bombs are such a great item to please all your guests. You can either wrap large ones individually in cute packaging or gift a set. Either way your guest will love an excuse to pamper themselves when they get home.
2. Mani Pedi Set
This is a classic baby shower game prize! You can buy a put together kit like this one. Or you can make your own with cute nail polish, a nail file, nail clippers, and some cuticle serum!
3. Press On Nails
For those who don’t want to paint their own nails, a press on nail set is just perfect! These are so easy to apply and last longer than most manicures, making it a favorite of just about anyone.
4. Skincare Gift Set
You’ll want to be sure you get something that fits with all skin types and sensitivities if possible. This Burt’s Bees Essentials set is sure to be a hit with everyone.
5. Home Oil Diffuser
Who doesn’t love coming home to a house that smells amazing? This home oil diffuser is not only beautiful but is so relaxing and welcoming. Add a few clean oils to the mix to make an amazing gift set.
6. Flowers or Potted Plants
Both a bouquet of flowers or a potted home plant would make a beautiful prize. You could also gift several small succulents in decorative vases and let your guests which one they would like! This would be perfect for any sort of woodlands or nature themed baby shower.
7. Cheeseboard
A fancy cheeseboard is something not everyone may own, but they may not purchase for themselves and would love to have for entertainment.
8. Aprons or Kitchen Towels
Aprons or kitchen towels would make a great prize because they something that just about everyone can use and could even be more special if you personalize them! And with so many different beautiful designs and prints it should be easy to match them with the theme of the baby shower!
These would be great prizes for a Freezer Meal Baby Shower!
9. Ice Cream Sundae Gift Basket
You could easily make your own Ice Cream Sundae basket for a prize! Find a cute basket and include everything they could need for a sweet treat, except the ice cream of course! Some options include an ice cream scoop, various types of syrup, toppings, cones or bowls, and spoons.
10. Local Honey or Jam
Depending on your area, check out any homemade local goods like jams, honey, or salsas from a local farmers market. Chances are your guests haven’t ever tried them before! We gave fruit syrup from a local farm near our home at our baby shower and I still get requests to bring some home whenever we visit.
11. Notebook or Journal
12. Summer Items
Now this is very time of year dependent, but there are endless opportunities for great baby shower game prizes for a party held at the beginning or during the summer. Think anything that could be great for the summer like:
- Beach towels
- Sunglasses
- Beach bag
- Sunscreen and sun care items
- Pool Floaties
There are so many great options that your guests are sure to love!
13. Tea/Coffee/Hot Chocolate Sampler
A sample of the hot drink of your choice would be a great prize for a baby shower in the cooler months. Pair a few flavors with a cute mug and you are set!
14. Gourmet Chocolates
A variety of gourmet chocolates like this Ferrero Rocher Assortment is sure to be a hit.
15. Coffee Table Books
A coffee table book is a great addition to any sophisticated home décor. There are several titles that may appeal to a variety of interests such as:
- Magnolia Table
- The Art of Home
- USA National Parks: Lands of Wonder
- There and Back: Photographs from the Edge
16. Cookie Cutter Set
For the baking lover select fun cookie cutter sets and pair them with a matching towel or other kitchen utensil.
17. Silicone Baking Cups
Silicone baking cups are a kitchen novelty that many of your guests may not own. For more the baking lovers this would be a highly sought after baby shower game prize.
18. Milk Frother
For coffee and hot chocolate lovers, a milk frother is a must! If you want to add more to the prize tie it to a small Torani syrup bottle with a cute bow.
19. Portable Phone Charger
A portable phone charger is a great prize, especially for teens who may be invited to the baby shower. You never know when you could need one!
20. Fitness Gear
There are so many small fitness gear items that could make great prizes such as water bottles, yoga mats, exercise bands, or even a massage gun.
21. Art Prints
There are so many gorgeous art prints and quotes on Etsy that would make a great prize. Pick up some cute frames from the Dollar Store and you are all set!
22. Heatless Curls Gift Set
Heatless curls are all the rage right now so why not gift a satin gift set to your baby shower game winner! This is another gift that would be especially popular with the younger crowd.
23. Hot/Cold Tumbler
An insulated tumbler to hold hot or cold drinks is an easy choice. You can also add a bit extra and fill in the inside with some candy!
24. Adult Coloring Book
Bring out the child in all your guests with a great adult coloring book paired with some colored pencils or markers.
25. Card Games
Card games can be a great option for co-ed parties! Some of our favorites include:
26. Silicone Kitchen Utensils
These silicone kitchen utensils are easily one of my favorite gifts I’ve ever received, and I always have to share them with others.
27. Mini Waffle Maker
Mini waffle makers are so much fun! They come in all sorts of different patterns and shapes to fit all the different holidays.
28. Throw Blanket
Can you really have too many throw blankets? Select a beautiful color for this soft throw blanket (there are just so many options) and everyone will be fighting over it.
29. Homemade Goodies
If you are known for a special treat you made, homemade goods are a perfect, inexpensive option to gift as a baby shower game prize. As long as you are aware of allergies or restrictions, homemade treats wrapped up all nice make a beautiful prize.
30. DIY Bath Salts
Make some delicious smelling DIY bath salts like these made from essential oils. They are super simple to make (with just Epsom salts, coarse salt, baking soda, and essential oils) and would look beautiful in fancy mason jars.
31. Mason Jar Treats
There are so many different recipes out there for layer mason jar treats that include all the dry ingredients for a recipe. Some of my favorites are:
You could make all the same or have a variety of recipes to choose from.
32. Hand Soap Set
Non toxic hand soap sets not only look beautiful on a bathroom counter, but they are good for you too!
33. Electric Candle Lighter
Electric lighters are actually so cool! Just charge them up and you won’t have to worry about lighters with flames again.
The Best Baby Shower Game Prizes
That wraps up our list of the best baby shower game prizes that aren’t gift cards you should have at your party! Did you find something that stood out to you?
Whether you’re hosting a cozy gathering or a grand bash, these prizes are the perfect finishing touch for an unforgettable occasion. So, let the games begin, the laughter flow, and the joy linger.
Here’s to creating memories that last a lifetime!
Check out more great baby shower related content:
- How to Ask for Books Instead of Cards at a Baby Shower
- How to Host a Diaper Raffle at a Baby Shower
- How to Throw a Virtual Baby Shower
- Best Locations to Host a Baby Shower
- Baby Shower Thank You Cards: How to Write the Perfect Card
- The Ultimate Baby Registry Guide
- 12 Virtual Baby Shower Game Ideas That Will Keep Guest Laughing
- How to Host an Amazing Baby Shower on a Budget
- The 10 Best Baby Shower Alternatives for Modern Parents
If you are pregnant, check out these blog posts to help you prepare for your baby:
- Top 10 Things Your Labor Nurse Wants You To Know
- Preparing for Pregnancy: 7 First Trimester Must-Haves You Can’t Do Without
- 7 Tips for the First 7 Days of Breastfeeding
- Navigating Pumping at Work: Top 11 Tips for a New Mom’s Success
- Everything You Need to Pack in Your Hospital Bag
- The Ultimate Third Trimester Checklist
- Baby Medicine Cabinet Essentials
- How to Prevent Stretch Marks During Pregnancy
- Postpartum Must-Haves for a Vaginal Delivery
